[quote="Alberich":38dn5mng]A - would be ridiculously spammy, tanks especially die all the time
B - quite alot of people do not like having it gossiped when/where they die - invites pthieves to hang out near recall point. This is why there is ICQ, or sitting in channels.
C - druids and necros do get a bit of an advantage for self-cr's (druids with low-level shiftable forms, necros with undead visage) but anyone who bothers to sit and think about it can generally figure out how to get their crap back. Pretty much every class has one skill or another that is usefull for self-cr's, if you think about it - my normal tactic is to mirror up, sneak into room with my corpse, and keep disengaging enough to carve corpse, while fleeing/remirroring as needed. Obviously that won't work for a non-mage-prime, but you get the idea.[/quote:38dn5mng]
Not arguing any of these points. For one, I did suggest a toggle, two I don't know the range something like this would have. Third, often when someone dies, someone will gossip for a raise. Fourth, when you drop channel, someone still has to vision you and then gossip for a raise, and even directions if they don't know where you are. I've seen this happen many times, though probably much less than there are deaths.
ICQ is the great equalizer, but shouldn't be a requirement for playing the game. I've used it myself, but as a solo, and worse, being somewhat unaffiliated with the current playerbase, this seems like an imposition.... maybe I'm wrong.
I also know how to get my corpse back, unless it's been looted, in which case most of us need some degree of help. There are basic tactics that literally ANYONE can use, much less class specific abilities. I won't insult you by listing them. However, anything that stops a mob from hating you, even temporarily, has other uses that are advantageous, if not readily apparent, especially as a solo.
As far as the resurrection aide issue, my perfect answer would be the 'dying breath report'. You may recognize the name if you've ever been in the military. Basically, it allows someone who's fallen to send a final report saying they are dead. Not sure the exact way you would implement this in MUD, but the military uses the concept so they can accurately track losses on each side during excercises. This would nicely sum up your arguments because it would allow you to:
tell impz Come raise me, I'm dead!
without alerting the entire mud. Of course, if Impz is sleeping, you're SOL
Of course, implementing it would be more difficult... this would perhaps work best as a 'bond of brotherhood' skill. You could bond with another player (hopefully you know another player), and then when you die, they get a psychic flash of your death (ie. they have a vision of you, in the room, being slain by monster x, a perfectly timed 'vision' basically) This could come across as a dream if need be, so if the person you're bonded with is asleep, they still see the vision. This answers MANY questions, and assures privacy. Also, this could perhaps help out our good friends the Isatars... or maybe it would just create too heavy of a dependance on them
Just ideas, comments still welcome.