Morning sirs,
@Ezekiel:
Looking at the practice, I see that this has happened before with King DeGrance and the diamond rings. The same exp groups would split, with those honor fellows resting prior to splatting the king, while the nonhonor fellows quickly dispatched him. So practice, I saw that it did work. Was it slightly annoying? Probably. So things require a bit more attention and decisiveness in one of the easiest exp zones in the game. Oh no.
@Toxis:
Are you talking about this "arguement":
Chobbs[engrish]> 'just a heads up, when i get around to it, the honor loss will probably be returned to marsup'
Chobbs[engrish]> 'he's tied to the honor system, i'm not sure why it was removed'
Toxis[engrish]> 'really?'
Chobbs[engrish]> 'it looks like he was meant to give you acess to some vault?'
Chobbs[engrish]> '*access even'
Toxis[engrish]> 'ah, I think I know what you mean'
Chobbs[engrish]> 'but there's a lot of honor related stuff'
Toxis[engrish]> 'never done it though'
Chobbs[engrish]> 'i don't know why it was removed'
Chobbs[engrish]> 'but just giving you fair warning'
Toxis[engrish]> 'nods'
Toxis[engrish]> 'well I got my 2 shields, I'mhappy'
Chobbs[engrish]> 'too busy now to return it, but it will'
Toxis[engrish]> 'kinda funny, we were 8 deep in calling marsup

'
Or the part where you stated things similar to what ezekiel said and I simply agreed that they were points.
@Blackmore:
So a standard BH exp group might not run it. A smaller, more dedicated group could quite easily, probably even right now. My proposed change would greatly reduce the honor lost, but nothing that can't be easily recouped several times over just by hitting say, uhhhl once. Heck, even one clear of sidhes would probably be enough to fix two or three runs of marsup. I'm just concerned with having near top end eq within such ready access of a ridiculously easy exp area without any real danger of running him.
@13:
Yup.
Chobbs!